JB's thoughts on American Idol
Copyright 2010 SpeakFree Media Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Share your thoughts about Idol -  jb@jbonair.com
Wednesday, February 3
A full night and a delayed response about my thoughts. Since tonight's show was a best-of-the-best type thing I needed to make sure I wasn't as wowed as the judges. And I wasn't. Let's go.
Amanda Shectman with the Britney Spears voices and who looks like a thinner Adele was OK. Way too dramatic as the judges pointed that out and were making fun of her. Despite being good, I can see myself hating her because of her pageant queen ways. She reminded me of that chick from the other season that came with her own press kit and cried about everything and had an annoying laugh. What's her name? And where is she now?
Lee Dewyze was good and oddly looked like offspring if Kris Allen and Danny Gokey mated. And where are those two now, anyway?
Michael Lynche's muscles were deceiving. Totally didn't imagine this big hulky guy to have such a soft romantic sound. He's interesting.
Aaron Kelly's The Climb was great. I wish they would have let him sing a little more. But he'll definitely get the screaming teen girl vote.
Hope Johnson the poor girl who never knew it was good. I really liked her. I'm rooting for her, but once again I think she's lacking the edge to make her stand out. Yes, she has a personality but is it big enough to push through the other biggies that'll be going to Hollywood week?

Tuesday, February 2
An early morning today with the Oscar nominations so I nodded off twice during Idol but I eventually got through the whole show. And maybe it's just because I was well rested that I didn't mind sitting through the whole thing. And how about the male nudity tonight? Wow. Kara once again whoring it up and having a guy take off his shirt. Bikini Boy Ty Hemmerling getting his 47 seconds of fame. Let's recap the best and worst of the Denver auditions.
Kimberly Kerbow, who we previewed on the Wrap Up today, was great. I love her smile and, sorry to be a Posh here, but she looked amazing. Good voice, good look, she could go a long way.
Crying basketcase Danelle Hayes reminded me of Pink with her style. Unfortunately, Danelle had no confidence and looked weak when talking but when it came to singing, she was a powerhouse.
Tori Kelly who brought the kindgarten class was 16 years old but looked older than me. I am 27. I've noticed lots of these teenagers look very old and when I rewind to see their age I'm surprised. Regardless, she is a good singer. Not too memorable but she was OK. Honestly, I finished watching the show about 10 minutes ago and I have no idea what she sang.
Strangely I liked football player Austin Paul. I didn't think he was that bad. I think the cocky attitude worked and would see him fit right in in Hollywood.
The girl from Italy whose voice was affected by the altitude (I'm guessing. Simon said helium) was interesting. Her speaking voice annoyed the hell outta me but the singing voice wasn't too bad.

Wednesday, January 27
It was 15 minutes into tonight's show and we'd only seen two auditions. While I would usually find that to be a waste of time, strangely this season that time is flying by. Why? I'm not sure. The guest judges don't do much either, but I'm not bothered by that. What's up with my mood?
Kimberly Carver's original song was great. I'm just not sure how Randy knows she "can blow." Was there a pre-interview?
Dave Pittman did very well and I think will go far in the competition.
Toddrick's original song -- that we previewed on Entertainment Wrap Up -- was so catchy and had me moving along on the couch. It shows that he's musically creative.
I enjoyed Maegan Wright who had the overly peppy brother. She reminded me of the classy Kelly Clarkson who was genuinely proud of herself and not cocky. Very classy, Maegan.
Tuesday, January 26
The good news about the circus of L.A. freaks was that the one hour flew by. Lots of time spent showcasing the oddities but is that what made the show fast? I'm not sure. The guest judges (Avril and Katy) were next to useless (despite how much I like them) and didn't offer up anything substantial. And we spent a lot of time learning about crazy freaks that didn't stand a chance taking a hop over to Hollywood. So, what did we learn tonight? Nothing really.
The bright spot was the Danny Gokey sound-alike whose parents were former gang members. Provided he's not caught on someone's "turf" before Hollywood week, he should do well in the competition.

Wednesday, January 20
I did pay attention to a few of the auditions and I made an observation: the people that don't have an interesting back story or some sort of cheesy entrance get very little screen time. Have you noticed a quick rip through of good singers? They literally get five seconds of airtime. Why? Because there's nothing to them except the good voice -- which is ironic to write since the show is allegedly trying to find the next best singer!
Capturing my attention tonight was Shelby, the final contestant on day 1. Also, the Beatles beatboxer was awesome. I'm not sure why the judges hesitated. The hair sisters were cute and charming and the bank robber was great.

Tuesday, January 19
A quick show tonight. Not too many memorable auditions. Seemed like the hour flew by. What's my highlight of the night? When Shania Twain loses it and gets flirty and giggly. She's such a Canadian!
As for the auditions, there's that, um, what's her name? Boobflex chick? She perhaps had a bubbly (and busty) personality but was somehow surprised she wasn't taken seriously by the judges. Imagine that: you go in there talking about doing a trick with your boobs and then are amazed you get laughed out of the room.
Charity, the daughter of the hairdressers, was great. Great voice. Seems like she could be a little shy but I really liked her.
Ms. Warrant and Family Tragedy is getting another shot and I'm going to check the Vegas odds to see what people are predicting will have her removed from the competition this year.
I also enjoyed Bryan Adams sound-alike Keith Semple, however, I think doing Adams songs and sounding like him will just get him the reputation of a celebrity impersonater.

Wednesday, January 13
My patience is wearing thin and it's only the second day of auditions. I have a theory that these first few shows are done more for entertainment value and the seriousness (if you can call it that) of the competition will begin during Hollywood Week. But regardless, here's my thoughts from tonight's show:
The beauty pageant loser didn't wow me. I thought she missed all the big notes during her Titanic song. She couldn't quite get past the hump with the power notes and it fell flat for much of the chorus. The judges loved her, so what do I know?!?!
Miriam Lemnouni should've been shown more. She was great. I don't recall what she sang, but that's the note I made about her.
The church singer/mom caretaker guy gave me goosebumps on the back of my neck. I don't recall in recent memory someone doing that on Idol. Is that a sign of things to come from him? We'll see. And coincidentally, he was wearing the Idol logo colours!
TV host Christy was too zippy and I figured she was on there as a sham. She was wanting to promote whatever the hell her show is. But if it's a morning show, my cripes, I'd wanna drown in my Froot Loops before listening to that.
Holly, the guitar girl/Kellie Pickler look/sound-alike, was adorable and a great singer. She's entertaining and I think has enough personality to charm her way through the competition. Will she get to the end? Probably not. But she'll get some kind of entertainment gig from this.
Mallorie from South Dakota who sang Piece of My Heart was awesome. I think she's got talent but maybe a little too wholesome for Hollywood. I wanna see those claws!

Tuesday, January 12
The emails start coming before the show is even over. I love it! Thanks to our dedicated audience for keeping me in the loop of your feelings. One person said we should hear from the people booted off the show. I name names on here, so if you see your name, feel free to give me a shout! Let's get to the first audition recap of the new season.
Maddy Curtis, the good 16-year-old sister, is great. She's got a great personality and is so caring. Wow, is Hollywood gonna eat her alive! But good luck!
Amadeo and his very close plastic-glass-wine-drinking family is adorable but I'm afraid for the judges' safety if he gets booted in the coming rounds. I'm just saying!
Mere Doyle, the Japanese cartoon lover -- who admittedly has 14 years of training and been to hundreds of auditions -- just answered her own questions about why she hasn't been discovered: "hundreds of auditions." People must be doing something right to keep this gem hidden!
Luke Shaffer, who kinda looks like David Beckham, has a great style and great look. I think it's that that'll get him through the competition more so than his sound. He's good, but I'm not sure if he's that good.
Ashley Rodriguez (who we previewed on the Wrap Up) did Alicia Keys perfectly. Let's watch her go far in the competition if her sweetness doesn't get in the way. Bring out the claws in Hollywood week!
Justin Guarini look-alike Tyler Grady (who broke his hands or arms or whatever) is good but might be a little too Sideshow Bob for the non-zany Idol audience. Again, he's good, but maybe too out there?
Mike Davis -- the boat guy -- reminded me of a non-nerdy Danny Gokey. He's charming and has a great personality and that'll probably win him a lot of votes.
Joshua Blaylock, the shy timid guy they wanted to tell Simon to shut up, is the boy next door type. He's got sex appeal for being a southern gentleman, but again, I think he's in for a rude awakening in Hollywood. And that sucks because I think if he comes out of his shell he'll be fine.
Finally, Justin Williams, who I believe Fox wants us to remember as "the cancer hottie" is amazing. He's my pick for the night. He's got a long time left in the competition.